Andrew was born and raised in the California Bay Area and attended Georgetown's School of Foreign Service. After spending a year working at a law firm serving inmates on Texas's death row, Andrew began his acting journey in New York City. For many years he worked and trained in the city, while taking regional theater roles upstate. In 2018, he and his wife Samantha moved to Los Angeles, where he works regularly in film, television, commercials, voiceover work, and virtual reality.